2005 - Dave Patterson, Golf
2004 - Tim Imafidon, Soccer
2003 - Brad Franklin, Baseball
2002 - Savio Nazareth, Golf
2001 - Clint Fields, Golf
2000 - Chad Coward (Baseball), Jimmy Lamour (Football)
1999 - David Heggie, Football
1998 - Junior Lord, Football
1997 - Steve Diamond, Lacrosse
1996 - Kevin Pendergrast, Tennis
1995 - Bryan Garland, Football
1994 - Cannon Morgan, Golf
1993 - Steve Foulks, Baseball
1992 - Calvin Hunter, Football
1991 - Chris Haarlow, Golf
1990 - Bill Beck, Lacrosse
1989 - Lee Porter, Golf
1988 - John Burke, Lacrosse
1987 - Rob Odom, Golf
1986 - Darryl Dozier, Basketball
1985 - Pernell Jefferson, Football
1984 - David Hood, Soccer
1983 - Bill Brooks, Golf
1982 - Bryan Savage, Lacrosse
1981 - Marty Block, Football
1980 - Robert Linville (Golf), Bill Stephans (Tennis)
1979 - Mark Guenther, Baseball
1978 - Elton Gross, Basketball
1967 - Tommy Grayson, Football, Basketball, Baseball
1966 - Chuck Scott, Basketball
1962 - Frank Bailey
