2005 - Courtney Hill, Basketball
2004 - A.J. Robertson, Volleyball & Basketball
2003 - Jennifer Pue-Gilchrist, Volleyball
2002 - Amy Evans, Basketball & Soccer
2001 - Arden Miller, Basketball
2000 -
1999 - Alison Schott, Basketball
1998 - Laura Haynes, Basketball
1997 - Betsy Parker, Tennis
1996 - Sara Johnson, Volleyball
1995 - Trudy Buckingham, Volleyball & Tennis
1994 - Brenda Davis, Volleyball & Basketball
1993 - Julie Sullivan, Lacrosse
1992 - Laura Klingseisen, Volleyball & Basketball
1991 - Jill Daly, Tennis
1990 - Corrie Gold, Basketball
1989 - Stephanie Aylward, Soccer
1988 - Jennifer Hunter, Tennis
1987 - Jennifer Friend, Tennis
1986 - Julie Tupper, Tennis
1985 - Sharon Vanis, Volleyball
1984 - Amy Parrish, Softball
1983 - Kerry Kennedy, Tennis
